Tuesday, May 3, 2011

别把华社摆上台





马华总会长蔡细历日前的一番“马华惨败不当官”言论,一石激起千层浪,不少评论人将之诠释为“破釜沉舟”。主观而言,蔡细历为了激起党内的斗志,此番“裸退”的豪言确实有其必要;客观而论,衡量马华现时的名望与形象,蔡总上述言论也只是“顺势而为”,没有大惊小怪的必要。

不过激励归激励,政治人物不能为了选战策略而歪曲事实,危言耸听。蔡细历近期“再惨败后不当官”、“马来西亚走向两种族线制”言论,皆建立在一个推论基础上:只有华人支持反对党

然而,此推论是否与事实相符,朝野自然有不同诠释,我们不妨参考局外人的看法。由新加坡管理大学东南亚研究学者Briget Welsh针对砂州选举成绩作出的统计显示,与上届州选比较,本届反对党所得华人票增加13.4%,与此同时,伊班票增加14.2%、比达友票增加17.9%、马来票增加18.4%、高原乌鲁人的选票更增加20.5%!这番数据,早有多位评论人引用,奈何蔡细历及其幕僚非但视而不见,反而刻意将华裔选民扭曲为唯一支持反对党的族群,更多番突出“土著在朝,华人在野”的论述。

我们可以理解,这是蔡细历为了挽救摇摇欲坠的马华而下的一剂猛药,可是这剂猛药,却可能会成为陷华社于不义的一剂毒药。过去两年多以来,种族极端份子伺机而动,种族叫嚣不绝于耳,许多牵涉全民利益的课题皆备扭曲为种族课题。一些极端份子甚至将城市选民基于对两线制的期望而支持反对党的投票取向,歪曲为“华人反对马来人政府”的荒谬结论。

如今蔡细历的连番言论,不但无助于舒缓非理性的种族叫嚣,反而正中部份极端份子下怀:“你看,连马华总会长都说华人反政府了!” 这类以种族眼光检视一切、诠释一切的言论,伤害的不只是处于萌芽阶段的两线制,而是我们最珍贵的各族之间的互信。

马华应该慎重思考的是,如果支持反对党的只有华人,为何日前首相会再度邀请回教党加入国阵,以“促进马来人团结”?可见求变之风,不只是华人单一族群的专利。

蔡细历要是真的打算破釜沉舟,带领马华背水一战,其实矛头不应该指向华社,逼迫华社二选其一。马华真正应该破的“斧”、沉的“舟”,更不是内阁的几个部长、州行政议员、或村长官职。马华必须明白,
华社最在意的不是马华代表是否当官,而是马华代表当官之后能否为民请命?而华人之所以唾弃马华,不是因为马华的官位太大,而是因为马华数十年来“当官不当权”!

是什么因素导致马华“当官不当权”?这道问题,如果蔡细历答不来,全国华裔同胞可以代答,正是因为马华公会在国阵内没有获得平起平坐的对待,空有执政之名,没有执政之实。

所以,如果蔡细历想要重振马华,赢回华社的尊重,方法只有一个,不是告诉华人:“如果你不投我,下届我不当官”;而是告诉其执政伙伴:“如果我们不能平起平坐,马华没有留在国阵的必要!

27 comments:

lri$ said...

沙发~

这是狗急跳牆,越跳越强,只是不知道會不會撞牆~~~

卖博士 字:孔明 said...

yah....
you tell exactly what i feel!!

pls send this article the CSL and get his assistant to translate to him.!!!

Caroll said...

~马华必须明白,华社最在意的不是马华代表是否当官,而是马华代表当官之后能否为民请命?而华人之所以唾弃马华,不是因为马华的官位太大,而是因为马华数十年来“当官不当权”!~

这句拍烂手掌!一针见血!

Cinn said...

国阵的处事方式是永远都不会看到自己的错,只有他人才有错。这就是为何他把责任都推给了华人,却不想想为何华人反他。
既然如此,咱们就错到底,下届大选咱们就让他们归西。

Anonymous said...

CD finally has to open out his last card, as he realise he has to go if the coming general election results not better than previos term, his party will accuse him for uncapable to capture more seats lost in last election. Secondly, by throwing out threaterning to chinese community to support otherwise refuse to be appointed in cabinet and other ranks in the government, merely to cover up if he fails in leading the party winning the next general election.
His bottle neck proposals has caused the party to an extreme and unrecoverable, therefore he has to go in either way.
However, it is radiculous for his supporters remain to be blind as his intention obviously annoyed more people and has not shooting arrow at the right focus.
Chinese community still regret of his actions for not be able to put-it-right to gain supports.

A Parent

黄俊玮Ng Jun Wei said...

没有马华华人就没有代表权?不是说satu malaysia吗?原来他们的satu malaysia是这样的,rakyat didahulukan是有条件的,你不投票给他们,你就不是他们的rakyat.

在民主社会里,反对党的责任是监督政府的工作,挑出行政上的错误,鸡蛋里挑骨头的话更好,这样人民才会知道真相,政府才会警惕自己。对我来说,蔡细厉是一个绝望的政客,人只有绝望时,才会说出这种负气话。也许是破釜沉舟,但目标应该是巫统,不是一群原先对他们抱有希望的华人,不是一群老板。陈莲花说选民有问题就会找执政党帮忙,执政党帮了,票投给反对党。请问这是交易吗?这是执政党的责任啊!修路,建学校等都是政府的基本责任啊!天底下哪里有执政党会拿他们本身应该做的事情来邀功的?天底下哪里有执政党威胁(很明显是威胁)选民的?

蔡细厉所说的话也许能拉回一些上了年纪的华裔选民的票,因为他们也许会害怕。可是年轻选民(我还不到年纪,不是选民)敢放手一搏,赌自己的未来,因为回教国再也不是威胁(我国有宪法保护,回教党也得不到三分二的支持来修改宪法,加上现在回教党的新一代领袖早已知道回教国的理念在马来西亚行不通,还有马来西亚不已经是回教国了吗?回教化在巫统领导下是循序渐进的),而且贪污腐败滥权绝对比回教国还要可怕。

只要民联政府好好经营,改善不足,再多两届大选,国阵政府一定会被推翻,加油!!

Anonymous said...

但是即使馬華和污桶平起平坐又怎樣?它和污桶一樣格局小,格調低,只會花錢粉刷門面搞好看不好吃的公關,沒有治國的能力。看那交通,房屋,衛生和那燕燕的遊山玩水部,只要聽其言,觀其行,就可知道他們的思維落後,連基本職責都分不清,毫無格局的亂七八糟。比我們資源少的鄰國都搞的比我們有聲有色,大馬還能浪費多少個年頭?要等到讓印尼也爬過我們的頭,如以前的菲律賓給周圍國家爬過頭?
為什麼要民主?就是要讓我們有機會和權力選有德和有能的團隊治國。人民給了國陣很多機會,爾等不是沒珍惜就是沒能力,既無心也無力,還厚顏無恥的胡說八道,別無選擇,唯有狠狠的用選票教訓你們。
華社,土權的。。。政府該照顧的是全體人民和國家的利益,聽全體人民的聲音,別再搞分而治之的那一套啦!

冒聰的吳啟聰 said...

行动党最大的悲哀,莫过于行动党就只能拿国阵的华基政党来开刀,对于巫统和其他土著政党却是一点办法都没有。号称“多元种族”的行动党,为何要把马华民政当作理所当然的宿敌?如果真的坚信自己是多元种族,为何会没有信心争取最大种族的支持?!!!!!!

Anonymous said...

No need to wait until next election. All MCA ministers can resign tomorrow & CD dissolve MCA immediately. Since CD already known majority Chinese not support MCA. Why stay?

凌国文 said...

吴启聪,

针对你所关注的课题,我早前刚写了一篇:《无谓的口水战》,欢迎指教。

Anonymous said...

MCA will have no guts to tell his master about the inequality treatment in BN. They dare not even got the guts to tell Perkasa and Utusan Melayu about their 1 Bumi 1Melayu slogon!Chua CD had said it clearly if they perform badly MCA will still remain in BN. So don"t expect them to resign the hard begged posts!

Anonymous said...

Something to share with all who are reading this. MCA Leaders only have guts to tell Chinese newspaper (like Chinese press & sin chew) if they NOT agree with UMNO, Perkasa, government policy & racist gov. servant. Some Chinese (I'll said those typical Chinese who are only read Chinese newspaper) were believed them really 'voice out' for Chinese.In fact, this is their trick. What is the point to show your disagreement and fight back within Chinese community? You can't find they strong disgreement in Malay or English press or media. I've observed these quit long-time ago. Please share this with your uncle or auntie who only read Chinese newspaper, this will give them a different prosective or view. Thanks.

Anonymous said...

"Ha Chiu"! The very fact that those who were rejected by their constituents in the last GE yet shamelessly sneaked in through the back door into the cabinet is self evident of what this junk party's true character is. Have they got a tint of dignity, MCA should have resigned from the cabinet, why have to wait till the next election? Why bother to get the rejected goods from the reject shop into the cabinet and why bother to recommend a young horn, CSL's puppy son to take up cabinet post?
Just can't imagine there is still such thick and shameless people still supporting such a good for nothing except to line their own pockets and talk cock party with such a pea brained yet very unbecoming character president! The Donut wanted to write his name upside down if he were to lose to LKS in Malay majority constituency but I would recommend him to change his party name first to something like "Malays Controlled Association" before he opened his mouth else the challenge and upside down name will be meaningless. This kind of rejected product with such mentality being put into the cabinet! God save Malaysia!

Ptui Seah said...

挺,一针见血。。

入阁当宦官,不如去荷兰!

yeo said...

马华当不当官都不重要!
执政当官数十年来都不当权!
早已违抵华社心愿!!

马华如果真的想突破现今的格局,
马华没有必要再留在国阵!
这或许能促使下届大选早点到来,
成就华社意愿!

Anonymous said...

其实,马华能不能当官并不重要,马华的胜负有谁会去担心。那五十年不变的“走狗”叛军党。如果猪有少许智慧也不回相信马华可以为马来西亚华人的做些什么。我本人认为那“老色”也太高估自己了。

Anonymous said...

to 吴ccb启$$聪, go suck dick of chuacd and stop calling yourself DR.

caucibai

冒聰的吳啟聰 said...

樓上的,請小心您的遣詞用字,不要人生攻擊,不要讓人家以為國文兄的支持者是超級百般沒有文化的!

文兄,馬華並沒有擺華社上台,是火箭反應太激烈罷了!

Anonymous said...

Dr, you got it wrong. With or without DAP, the right minded Malaysian taxpayers can't tolerate MCA and folks like you anymore.

lri$ said...

to doctor :
you still dont get it dont you?
this essay is not about DAP shooting MCA or helping DAP....
this essay is about what do the chinese think about the the speech--马华惨败不当官
and beside i cant find anything that is related to DAP
he point it out already, if the MAC cant be equal with the UMNO, MCA should leave BN

Anonymous said...

卖华没有摆华人上台?

好,那么我们来问, 究竟华人又没有说要取消土著特权? 

没有!

但,卖华的菜cd一直强调什么“华人的要求不切实际”,或“他菜cd支持公正党如果他们能够取消马来特权”云云。

这不是借口是什么?
这不是“摆华人上台”是什么?

卖华分明就是在符合污桶的外论,刺激及加强马来人的危机感,使马来人相信华人是极端的,华人是过分的!

这是卖华“捍卫华人利益”的方式?

这是赤裸裸的“逼华人吃死猫”!

卖华分明就是在无所不用其极的维护污桶,就算建立在危害华人的利益也在所不惜!

每一次菜cd卖华都在自欺欺人的逼华人吃死猫!
华人要的是减少贪污滥权,公正,华人从来没有反对政府对贫穷马来人的帮助,只不过不能认同卖完豪宅也有discount!

但,卖华就是喜欢歪曲华人的用意,配合污桶来抹黑华人!

当“底衫电视台”或“五毒散”大标题报道:
卖华指责华人不好过分要求;卖华说华人制造种族两线制;华人不支持卖华因为卖华不能废除土著特权。。。

你觉得如果你是马来人,你有什么感想?你对华人有什么看法?

你敢说卖华菜cd不是“以华人代表身份来抹黑华人”?

这种垃圾的卖华党,你要我投票给他?
呐!

Anonymous said...

还有,
华人不支持卖华的原因及用意是什么?

1)华人不要卖华进入内阁!

2)华人不要卖华继续充当污桶的打手!


那些人一直强调,这是民主/不是威胁!

但,为什么菜cd很勇敢的决定“不加入政府”,却不敢“脱离刮阵”?

这就是所谓《柿子挑软的吃》!!

因为蔡cd不敢得罪刮阵!

这不是“威胁华人”是什么?

你有种威胁华人,但为什么没有种“威胁”污桶?! 

因为蔡cd知道,如果他说《卖华将退出刮阵》,那么卖华将输到一席不剩! 
因为卖华知道,所有华人将确保卖华下一届“退出刮阵”!
而他的所谓的党要也将准备加入刮阵直属党员!

奉劝火箭别纠缠在“退出内阁”,与卖华起舞!

火箭/蓝眼应该改变战略,公开挑战卖华,公开挑战卖华宣布:

如果大选成绩差,卖华将退出刮阵!

如果卖华不敢宣布,就代表他们害怕污桶甚于华社。

火箭蓝眼应该质问卖华,为什么宁愿威胁华社也不敢”背叛“污桶!

普通市民 said...

100%認同樓上的無名所言。貪腐,濫權,不公不正,黨政不分明,政府機構變政黨打手甚至成殺手,利用公器散播色情小電影,簡直是無法無天,叫為人父母兄姐的如何教導小孩和弟妹?學校老師如何引導學生?馬華即是執政黨的同盟,你的聲音呢?要你們這些政黨閣員有何用?既被選民唾棄,又不是甚麼專才,更不是甚麼奇才,還要跑後門當官,這是甚麼示範?無德無能連甚麼是民主都搞不清,混撓視聽,故意誤導友族,挑撥離間,還敢威脅華裔選民,連基本為人的良知都沒有,還談甚麼誠信?只想當官而不懂職責為人民公僕卻又不懂反省的政黨,該是時候滾下台了。

凌国文 said...

大家心水都很清,不像上面那位冒牌货般搞不清楚状况。

Anonymous said...

The voters of Pengkalan Riting,Pulai Johor be aware! According to Sin Chew ,Johor edition, if the MCA loses in the election, the MCA branch will close it centre!

MCA mean nothing to all right thinking taxpayers said...

So?

Who cares even if MCA were to close its HQ other than its gullible members and supporters?

Anonymous said...

冒聰的吳啟聰 said...
樓上的,請小心您的遣詞用字,不要"人"生攻擊,

Are you human? I don't know M$A (or MSHITA) member/supporter are human?!

Don't fucking used your Dr title to cheap people lar. Dr title is only for HUMAN, not for M$A or MSHITA people. (eat $ of people, and eat SHIT of UMBoh).