Sunday, September 25, 2011

“开放言论自由”的南柯一梦


“希望越大,失望越大”这句话,对许多渴望“改革”的我国人民而言,恐怕早已习以为常。

首相刚在马来西亚日前夕向全民承诺开放言论空间,以满足人民对更广阔的民主空间的追求与期许。在支持者如潮水般的鲜花和掌声方兴未艾之际,日前突然再传本地制作的电视记录片遭政府腰斩的坏消息。



电检局最新的刀下魂,是NTV7《追踪档案》的一部题为《我要上学》的记录片。根据报道,该片于早前送往电检局审查时,已被勒令剪接掉部分内容,作为获准播放的条件。

虽然制作单位已按照指示作出剪接,可是电检局却在该片播放的前一天通知制作单位必须撤回该片,理由是“担心影响沙巴州的形象”。

这部记录片是如何“影响沙巴州的形象”呢?我们暂时无缘欣赏此片,固然不能作出评断,可是根据NTV7面子书页面上对有关记录片的介绍,我们大概可以理解:“1963916日,沙巴和砂拉越宣布加入马来亚半岛,组成了马来西亚。如今走过了48年的岁月,虽然拥有丰富的天然资源,但在经济社会发展、教育、基础设施等方面,沙巴与砂拉越依然相对落后。”

马来西亚成立以来,国阵每一届大选在东马主打的“发展牌”,早已耳熟能详。可是东马两州这些年来的“发展”成果,却也是有目共睹的。问题是,东马两州每况愈下的困境,却是旁观者清,当局者迷。这个“担心影响沙巴州形象”的腰斩行动,或许是不想让当局者从美梦中惊醒的努力之一。

节目被“美化”的经验,NTV7早已不是首次遇上。去年,时事清谈节目《非谈不可》节目制作人黄义忠就曾因为不满该台管理层向首相署和首相夫人的施压低头而自我审查节目内容,毅然辞职。

从早前涂黑《经济学人》杂志专文、到腰斩揭露“不能说的秘密”(尽管早已是公开的秘密)的《我要上学》记录片,广开言路的美梦,毕竟还是南柯一梦。

60 comments:

Anonymous said...

中国报》专栏作者凌国文,最近接受《中国报》副刊专访,其中介绍他的文字如下:


“凌国文是本地著名时事部落客,写下许多针贬时弊的文章,拥有大量读者。”


其中“针砭时弊”四个字有必要进一步讨论,因为只要读凌国文的文章就知道,他针砭的只是“国阵的时弊”,至于行动党和民联的一切时弊,几乎从没见他写过一个字,所以有关介绍词可能漏 掉了两个字,正确的说法应该是:


“凌国文是本地著名时事部落客,写下许多针贬国阵时弊的文章,拥有大量读者。”


试看最近的几个课题,麻坡行动党一个领袖动用向公众筹到的公款购买汽车自己用,被党员揭发举大字报抗议,凌国文对这个课题一粒字都没写。但是沙登马华区会一个小卒仔因为针对赵明福案,做了一个脑残短片,指责欧阳捍华害死赵明福,却惹来凌国文特别撰文嘲笑批评。


行动党的case涉及的是公众款项和领袖的清廉,凌国文视而不见,反而对一个马华小卒仔的无聊行为表现出大义凛然、挺身而出的正义姿态,可见凌国文的所谓“中立客观”标准与众不同。


凌国文为何没有对行动党和民联的劣行败德写过半粒字?大概有两个原因:


一,凌国文觉得行动党和民联十全十美,即使是劣行败德,在他眼中也是美好的,就算林冠英用屁股对着他放臭屁,他的反应,要么是赞美林冠英的屁芳香无比,不然就是大骂国阵执政下,管理民生食物不当导致林冠英放屁。


二,凌国文根本是行动党和民联的马前卒,所以只骂国阵,绝不批评行动党和民联。


但, 凌国文只能算是行动党的马前卒,而绝不是什么文胆,因为文胆起码他们真正能把主子交给他们的任务办妥,做得妥妥当当,而马前卒 呢,就是那些一心一意想要做主子的文胆文棍,为主子效劳尽忠,但问题是本身能力和素质有限,结果是越帮越忙,成事不足败事有余,为主子倒米,让主子厌恶无比。


举例:最近以讹传讹,指孟加拉外劳被国阵赠赐投票权的课题,事情还不明不白,根本毫无确凿证据,凌国文却过度心切为主子效劳,在完全无凭无据的情况下,迫不及待在面子书写道:“即然连孟加拉外劳都可以获得投票权了,纳吉需要改什么革?马来西亚早就是世界上最民主的国家啦!”


凌国文再次发挥他靠想象力写文章,在无真凭实据下把传闻当新闻、把谣言当事实,还有他砍头砍尾、断章取义的本领,绘声绘影指国阵给孟加拉外劳投票权。


国阵当然不是什么正人君子,但是稍微有脑的人也不会愚蠢到这种地步嘛。好啦,就假设国阵真的蠢到给孟加拉外劳投票权,但是有谁可以保证到时候他们肯定会投票给国阵?


抓外劳的官员都是国阵政府的,外劳早就对国阵积怨,肚懒国阵多过肚懒民联,到时候他们投民联的机会更高,国阵给他们投票权,不是拿刀子给外劳捅自己?


9月20日,孟加拉驻大马最高专员阿迪克拉曼澄清,孟加拉总理哈西娜根本不曾发表过在马来西亚工作的孟加拉工人可以获得马来西亚公民权,并获准在大选中投票的言论。针对网络媒体没有就相关声明之准確性向他求证便发佈报导,他也表示感到遗憾。可见,炒作这个课题的网络媒体无疑是在制造假新闻,在无根无据的情况下绘声绘影报道一些不利于政府的传闻,连最基本的向当事人求证的工作也没做,新闻专业沦落至此,难怪马来西亚政坛和舆论会群鬼乱舞、乌烟瘴气。


批评政府当然没有问题,也是天公地道,但是如果为了批评政府而制造假新闻、扭曲事实、把传闻当新闻来报导,那么这些网络媒体跟他们口中所批评的邪恶国阵有何分别?


像凌国文这种号称时事评论人,也竟然在完全没有事实根据的情况下,引述传闻来批评政府,现在事实被厘清后,也不见他为自己的胡言乱语道歉。所以说,文胆文棍绝对不会做出这种没有水准、充满漏洞的批评,只有马前卒才会犯下如此低级错误。


但是更应该头痛的是行动党和民联才对,如果他们继续用凌国文为马前卒,以他的钻牛角尖的评论,只会让越来越多的人对行动党和民联反感,帮行动党和民联倒米,所以行动党和民联还是花点心思找一些真正的文胆文棍为自己效劳吧,找半桶水的马前卒,最后是令人对行动党反感,得不偿失。

polo_c said...

哟,楼上的又来宣传千字文,真的辛苦你啦。
如果行动党领袖盗用公款为自私用怎么不见被反贪局请去喝咖啡??
这太不像反贪局的作风吧。。。

Anonymous said...

老林:“聂哥,你不要那么快宣布回教法啦,等我们骗了华裔票后执政了才宣布啦。”

聂老:“阿林,你傻的啊!现在我们马来票不保,你的又不够<...一个马来西亚>琅琅上口,印度人又不爽你们,单靠你华人票,我们怎样执政?”

老林:“但是你这样会吓到我们华人的叻,我下一届做不到副首相的叻!”

聂老:“你切了没有?”

老林:“还没有。。。但是我肯定切的。。嗯。。。好吧!我们有倪大炮和superman全国巡回骗人会,回教法课题我们会包装的!骗人的功夫,我们火箭最厉害!记得给我副首相哦~”

聂老:“哇靠!你算老几?我回教党还没分完,你以为你切了就能当啊?”

老林:“我也帮你骗了华人票,也支持你的回教法叻,第二副首相施舍一下也好啦~”

聂老:“你diam-diam啦!我讲没有就没有,不爽的话,滚出民联啦!我们都不要你!火箭,你滚啦!!”

老林:“不要这样啦,聂大哥!奴才愿意为你效劳一身,请你不要赶我走。。”

p/s:文兄,为何您没对回教法“歌颂”几句呢?

polo_c said...

嘿嘿,楼上的,老马早在N年前早已宣布大马是回教国,当时马华和民政怎么出声没反对呢??
大马联邦宪法没列明大马是回教国,怎么马华和民政没出声纠正老马的错呢??
可以告诉我为什么吗?
还有一件事,Terengganu 至今还实行着回教刑事法, 怎么马华和民政又没出声呢??
可以解答我的疑问吗??

Anonymous said...

1 Malaysia double standard !

Freedom of speech is only allow to speak on favour of the ruling party, criticide and comments are prohibited.

As general election in the countdown, media and networks shall be battle of arguements and expecting more of poison pens to belittle someone who has consitantly providing update informations in various aspects as a feedback to Malaysian.

Ignore those who intensionally counting chicken before hatches as they are merely nuisance.

A Parent

Anonymous said...

yoyo... c polo.. 难道你还是傻傻分不清楚什么是世俗回教国,什么又是回教刑事神权断肢法吗?

Anonymous said...

凌兄,朝庭江湖剌客找上門啦。

Anonymous said...

Dear friend,

Pls be aware of the political reality in Malaysia. First, only a malay and muslim can become Prime Minister at least in the next 20 years to come. so if we choose a muslim leader that only interested to promote islamic law and practice in our country, what future do we have, as a non muslim ? Our chinese have to think seriously, uner islamic law, non muslim is trated as second class, worse than present. all decision making is go the the council comnprising of ulama only. Do u like it ?

Anonymous said...

Anonymous of September 25, 2011 12:21 PM,

I'm surprised, don't you know that Islamic Law can only be applied to Muslims?

Don't you know that if anyone dare to apply Islamic Law against non- Muslims, the latter can bring the case to International Court?

Don't you know that Islamic Law can only be implemented if it were approved with majority in the parliament?

Don't you know that MCA & Gerakan goons were rebuked by Dr M for 'uncalled' for comments?! Why are the 2 goons so scared of Dr M???!!! They should rebut him, especially CSL, this is the golden opportunity for CSL to show off his boldness against the ex PM if he dares not do it to Nazri.

I'm not a Muslim and I have no fear of Islamic Law even if it were to be implemented. It should be those corrupted Muslims who got tons of ill gotten wealth need to be fearful. They better heed Dr M's advice to learn to hide their wealth, learnt from him to buy properties overseas and if possible even cattle/sheep/horse ranch in Argentina or MCA's ex 'daigo', Chan Kong Choy, to flash his wealth in Australia, US, China.....

Btw, can you please find out for us if Islamic Law allows 'Undilah' be shown in TV? ( Open an opportunity for you to write another piece of 'long' Chinese article which demands long suffering to read it.)

( From a Malaysian who has no desire to join any political party)

Anonymous said...

I am surprise that u all so naive. That shown you just read what politician siad without think. Go and study the counry that implment islamic law then u know what is islamic law impact to non muslim citizen. Under islamic law, firt there is no democracy and muslim is the first priority. Don't u understand. I know u hate BN and UMNO in particular but do u think PAs can govern our country better ? look at kelantan dan Kedah. What development is Kelantan people enjoy since last 20years ?

Anonymous said...

Malaysia needs a two-party system desperately. Period.

Anonymous said...

凌国文,懒趴!

qym said...

国文兄,polo_c,不要再和楼上几位辩论,我有一个堂兄是马X党X, 也有一样的思想逻辑。

Ming said...

对,别让费时间回答这些人!
我们是不会这么容易被引响到的。

凌国文 said...

呵欠。。。马华匿名枪手就只有这种水准?一点点失望啦(因为本来期望就不到)。

这些人永远看不到,或不想回答,要修宪把马来西亚变成完全实行回教刑事法的回教国(上面有一个说连非回教徒都被涵盖在内),到底需要什么条件?现实中可不可行?

这些人也永远看不到,或不想看到,就连回教党内的中央领袖也有不少是反对落实回教刑事法 / 回教国的(如果有看新闻的话)。要落实回教国,除了取得国会3份2议席修宪,回教党首先还得跨过自己党内的不同派系。

可是,马华每次都讲到好像很简单酱喔。。。

凌国文 said...

那位匿名英雄,加油,快点继续鸟凌国文,快点努力转移大家的注意力,别让大家关注NTV7记录片被腰斩、Undilah短片被禁播。。。加油!

凌国文 said...

qym,辩论?呵呵,你太看得起那位匿名英雄了。

Anonymous said...

文兄,这更本就不关修不修宪的课题,而是民联本身的合作问题。。
说好的民联白日新政橙皮书呢?哈哈哈。。都还没机会做政府,聂老,暗怒华等民联回教徒领袖已经变样了。。。别再欺骗无辜的选民了,只有猫头英迷才会信他们会遵守协议!!别再傻了,回头是岸,跟回教党谈福利国,谈世俗国。。他会叫你去吃草吧。。。

Anonymous said...

我可一點都不擔心那位說 “u all so naive” 而自以為大家胡塗只他獨醒的的匿名者說的。

How can you compare Malaysia with Iran, Iraq or the other middle East countries?! Before accusing others for only reading the lips of the politicians ( Which I'm afraid he is talking about himself /herself for listening too much of MCA's 'reaching' ), please do a study of the background and history of those countries. But beware not to learn from those BN approved historians whom can wipe out records of Malaysia hosting the Commonwealth game and Commonwealth Head Conference in KL .....

Please give an accurate account of how you can get 2/3 majority in the August House to approve changes required in the Constitution Law to turn Malaysia into Islamic State? Not until you can formulate a convincing possibilities, please keep your hands away from stirring shit else you may end up with mouthful of it.

With regards to development in Kelantan, you got the cheek to have such audacity to mention it! Has the federal government provide sufficient resources to Kelatan? What happened to the oil money owe to Kelantan for these umpteen years?

You go and take a look at the developed countries and come & tell us which of their central government dare to hold up development from an opposition controlled constituencies? If they dare, those electorates will dare to refrain from paying taxes to the central government.

qym said...

(除了取得国会3份2议席修宪,回教党首先还得跨过自己党内的不同派系) 喂! 匿名枪手你到底明不明白?连我12嵗女儿我解释给她听都能明白。

qym said...

国文兄,奇怪,怎么最近这麽多枪手hook你?

Anonymous said...

都说了,现在谈论的是民联立场的问题!试问一个立场摇摆不定的“组织”要人民如何取信呢?今天大纲是这样,明日呢是不是某人说了算。。。三头政纲不一样的乱马要它们如何朝一个方向跑呢???
ws

老百姓 said...

“都说了,现在谈论的是民联立场的问题!试问一个立场摇摆不定的“组织”要人民如何取信呢?今天大纲是这样,明日呢是不是某人说了算。。。三头政纲不一样的乱马要它们如何朝一个方向跑呢???”
是罗是罗!民联立场摇摆不定…
不过比起贵党的立场就是“无立场”!我还是笨笨的投给民联…
我就是那么的笨!

Anonymous said...

不好思我没看那些卖华的狗论,我只是看国文的文章,
只因我铁了心要狗阵倒一次, 各位朋友不用浪费时间去
回应他们,最重要的是让在小地方的亲戚朋友也与我们
一样要改变。如果民朕不好, 我们可以再换。

Anonymous said...

To my dear friend who posted his comment on September 26, 2011 12:25AM

Pls read the below article. This is certainly not written by pro BN columnist or newspaper. Of course you have every right and freedom to cast cast your vote to PR to form government. This is your choice in a democratic country.But once PAS formed government, your voting right will be taken away.

Islamic states get Western economic aid despite mass hatred towards non-Muslims

Lee Jay Walker

Modern Tokyo Times
http://global-security-news.com/2011/08/16/islamic-states-get-western-economic-aid-despite-mass-hatred-towards-non-muslims/

Anonymous said...

国文,看来卖华看中你了,请看下面
http://killghost39.blogspot.com/2011/09/blog-post_22.html
以后你就更出名了,哈哈!

Anonymous said...

Anonymous of September 26, 2011 9:24 AM, I have no dispute of what Lee Jay Walker's articles & I shared his feelings of the changes in Manchester and his country. However, the issue England facing is not just because of the Muslims, other migrants from Africa and India etc also constitute part of the reasons as what Enoch Powell pointed out in the '60s & '70s. I've read Barnabas Aid, the magazine of Barnabas Fund, and I know what is your concern. Thank you for telling us what we have known long before LJW's articles.

However, you have yet to tell us the main point, how do you get PAS to get 2/3 majority to form the government on its own without other supporting parties? They can't even get the majority of 'Muslims' in UMNO to heartily support it. C'mom, we all know why Khairy and the rest taking up this topic. This is the familiar shenanigans they're familiar with.

It is more likely for DAP to oppose such motion than MCA/Gerakan. The latter will sure agree if PAS can offer them ministerial posts and allow them to continue lining their own pockets.

So far, Mr Karpal S and LKS and the other prominent DAP leaders have displayed their integrity and stand on principle but I have seen none from MCA/Gerakan. Oh no, they do have personal 'principle' ie based on ministerial posts and personal gain offered.

To me, the immediate task for us voters is to get rid of all forms of corruption which is so rampant in this country. BN has managed this country and not only not able to soleve this issue, it is getting worse eg TBH & Sarbani's death. So, it is better to get BN to take a rest to reform itself.

Anonymous said...

到底是谁在“卖华”还不知呢?这边厢高喊民主;高喊马来西亚人的马来西亚;高喊代表多元种族的政党然而却只敢在华人区“以华制华”。。为了一园“副相梦”到最后应会:“ya betul ya betul, apa pun bolehlah....聂老都开声不满回教法可以滚了,真没鼓气-赖皮不走。。。。hohoho!!!
ws

Anonymous said...

哈哈哈!原来一样是龟笑鳖,一样bohood....

居安思危 said...

果然是言论自由啊!
百屁齐放!
乌烟瘴气!

Anonymous said...

Wonder why no supporters of MCA ever dare to touch on the subject of how to eradicate corruptions? 沒有馬華支持者敢回應 Nazri 和 馬哈帝?連馬華的副內政部長都不敢在土權面前呼大氣?衛生部長不敢在警務員面前保護醫院醫生護士和病人利益?

亚伯 said...

我的选区州议员还未当选时,有一次来我家谈心事。他是火箭的。因为家庭负担的关系,他在考虑是到吉兰丹做工呢,还是出来做候选人?我给他的意见是后者。结果他那一届就中选了,直到今天,20多年了。当时我分析马来西亚的投票趋势是。。要投民政,不如投马华,要投马华不如投行动党!到今天,他依然屹立不倒!

Anonymous said...

想必文兄可能接到“封口令”吧!为何闹得沸沸扬扬的回教刑事法却只字不提呢?还是真如所说的:”马前卒“,不顾民意,只选择性报导有利民联的新闻,失望咯!!!
ws

polo_c said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
meng on said...

卖华枪手竟折堕到如斯地步,要论证也只敢匿名,看来是位没春袋的公公吧?公公啊,这样藏头缩尾,躲在阴暗角落放冷箭的做法,很难引起共鸣的,毕竟现实世界里鼠辈横行不多。

polo_c said...

'要落实回教国,必须取得国会3份2议席修宪'

重点在这里,回教党国会议席有超过2/3吗??答案是没有,没有的话回教国论什么的闪一边去吧。。。
马华自认华人内阁代表又不见得去解决华社堆积如山的民生问题,54年了,贫民怒吼啊~~
马华文棍就如蔡会长永远都选则性看不到重点~~

风语者 said...

"为何闹得沸沸扬扬的回教刑事法却只字不提呢?"

Why is MCA so scared about 回教刑事法? This is an old topic they used to scare off the Chinese community.

Personally, after brain washed by MCA for so many years, I also quite afraid and resist of this 回教刑事法.

However, compared to the madness that happens under the BN ruling, 回教刑事法 is nothing compared to 明福案、蒙古女郎、贪官污吏、公开贪污腐化、公开纵容执法者犯法、公开妄顾人民生命批准危险工业、公开强奸民主自由法律等等。。。 那些才真正的可怕!

回教刑事法? Guess why MCA made it such a big issue because 蔡CD worry about getting his pp cut off.

polo_c said...

To 风语者:

Not pp, is LP^^

Anonymous said...

It is known as the fifth stick

Anonymous said...

風語者,you are absolutely right.

In the 1st place, MCA/Gerakan are opposing something which is not likely to happen. They never dare to highlight the main point that polo_c and many others have mentioned ie. how on earth PAS alone could get the 2/3 majority in parliament? Unless the 4th, 5th and 6th PM and their 子弟兵 all prepared to be without hands, tongues ....

Compare to all the viles that you have mentioned 明福案、蒙古女郎、贪官污吏、公开贪污腐化、公开纵容执法者犯法、公开妄顾人民生命批准危险工业、公开强奸民主自由法律等等 with Islamic State, the former issues, not only has already taken shape, but has become a deep rooted culture of BN's rulings while the latter, as mentioned, not possible now and can be of no issue once the imminent bad culture is corrected.

Anonymous said...

polo c 阿 polo c,我见议你还是多买几份报纸详读才来发言吧。。。今天聂老只是要在吉兰丹落实回教法,你说需要你那不知名的火箭议员的赞成票吗?需要靠其他人来帮他达到2/3的多数票吗?就只会模糊焦点,能骗就骗。。。。
ws

Anonymous said...

Dear Friend, pls read this article from kwong wah jit poh. Hope DAP friend can tell their boss to do something for the chinese in Kedah. They have suffered a lot under PAS rule. DAP pls stop cheating chinese

房屋政策·宰猪场·纠正滥权 吉民冀林吉祥助解决
http://www.kwongwah.com.my/news/2011/09/25/158.html

Anonymous said...

老兄,慢慢等吧,等久久。。。。你要叫dap去求回教党,哈哈!!!万一闹翻了,“副相梦”不是也跟着泡汤了,hohohoh....

Liang said...

哈哈,落实回教法,我不怕!我怕的是,明福案、蒙古女郎、贪官污吏、公开贪污腐化、公开纵容执法者犯法、公开妄顾人民生命批准危险工业、公开强奸民主自由法律等等!
明白吗?傻佬!

Jun said...

哈哈,落实回教法,我不怕!我怕的是,"明福案、蒙古女郎、贪官污吏、公开贪污腐化、公开纵容执法者犯法、公开妄顾人民生命批准危险工业、公开强奸民主自由法律等等"!
明白吗?傻佬!

qym said...

哈哈,落实回教法,我不怕!我怕的是,"明福案、蒙古女郎、贪官污吏、公开贪污腐化、公开纵容执法者犯法、公开妄顾人民生命批准危险工业、公开强奸民主自由法律等等"!
明白吗?傻佬!

Anonymous said...

好了,不要再谈狗了,不然林放狗名叫波力士的哈巴狗
来叫蕉吃。
谁有内幕何时大选?
我练了几招打狗棍法想试试。
哈哈!

凌国文 said...

对回教国课题的看法,我在上面的留言早就写了,可惜有人急着发难,来不及看。

至于激将法这种把戏嘛,早就免疫了。那位一人分饰多角的蒙面好汉,你可要加把劲了。:)

ws said...

今天聂老只是要在吉兰丹落实回教法,你说需要你那不知名的火箭议员的赞成票吗?需要靠其他人来帮他达到2/3的多数票吗?

Anonymous said...

Without the approval of Federal government, can " 聂老只是要在吉兰丹落实回教法"? If the majority of Kelantanese are Muslims and their choice is to support PAS, what is the issue?

Buddhists abide by the teachings of Buddhism, Christians abide by the teaching of Christianity, so let the Muslims abide by their Islamic Law, so long they don't impose it upon the non Muslims, I couldn't careless.

However, corruptions, nepotism & cronyism, and social injustice affects all of us, regardless of Buddhists, Christians or Muslims, so we care and want to weed it out for the betterment of our future generations and the nation.

凌国文 said...

WS,

奇怪,如果落实回教法真的那么容易,聂老为什么还不落实呢?

ws said...

因为聂老在等着火箭举手投足的赞成票啊!!!

凌国文 said...

哦,回教法无法实行,原来是火箭不投赞成票。

谢谢你的说明。

Anonymous said...

ws 捉虫了.........
国文你将人家军做什么?

Anonymous said...

官他甚麽回教法, 我只要bn倒一次,民联不好在让他滚蛋,bn狗急甚麽。

ws said...

哦,原来民联的成立主要是为了欺骗选票,表里不一,面和心不合,赶快解散吧还需高谈什么政纲什么橙皮书!

Anonymous said...

ws,

Why hide yourself here? Many are waiting for you in Mr Ling's latest article.

C'mon, don't be a coward!

凌国文 said...

语无伦次,是恼羞成怒的最大特征,哈哈!

有趣有趣!

Anonymous said...

great job , keep it up Jason

Anonymous said...

bn也不是一直在狗咬狗骨吗?赶快解散吧!