Wednesday, March 30, 2011

山埃、稀土、核电厂

为了经济利益,政府愿意让人民承受多大的风险?这是每一个发展中国家必须考量与挣扎的永恒命题。



从武吉公满的山埃冶金厂、格宾的稀土提炼厂、到最近引起热烈争论的核子发电厂计划,马来西亚政府在一片反对声浪中所展现的能人所不能的胆识,已经给了这道问题一个最果断的答案!


在一个经济发展被看重得近乎压到一切的社会,只要是打着促进经济发展旗号的,一切都会变得理所当然。我国政府正是以经济发展的堂皇理由,尝试说服人民接受上述充满争议的计划。


针对这个说法,有两道问题是我们必须思考的:首先,我们是否已经沦落到非要依靠发展这些高风险计划来维生不可了? 其次,这些计划是否值得让我们押上人民的健康安危作赌注



先说彭亨武吉公满山埃冶金厂。就算政府没有批准有关计划,该地居民数十年来还是安居乐业;而在政府于2007年批准有关计划后,当地的经济发展、基础建设,跟早前还是没有多大分别。就连该厂自称为居民创造的就业机会,现在也多由廉价的外劳所填补了。当地居民有幸“分享”的,只是一吨又一吨当局没有交待将如何安全处理的有毒石渣。



再说同样来自彭亨的格宾稀土提炼厂。“稀土”对于许多四、五十岁以上的大马人来说是再熟悉不过的字眼。70年代,日本财团在霹雳州红泥山开设稀土提炼厂。虽然当时的政府保证有关厂商的辐射废料埋毒地区符合安全规格,可是埋毒区后来却被检测出超标的辐射指数。在居民前扑后继的反对浪潮下,好不容易才逼使有关厂商结业。


我们似乎不曾从历史中得到教训,30多年后的今天,政府再度批准一个澳洲的厂商前来开设稀土提炼厂,让我国成为除了中国以外,近30年来全球第一个允许开设稀土提炼厂的国家。如果该厂一如政府所保证的“非常安全”,为何澳洲人要老远把稀土运到我国来提炼呢?


至于核子发电厂,则是到现在还叫人丈八金刚摸不着脑。我国的地理环境,充分具备发展水力发电、太阳能发电等再生能源的先天条件。不懂基于什么原因,我们的政府偏爱舍易取难,撇下既安全又环保的天然能源,追求高风险的核子发电。不幸中的大幸,日本核危机为民众上了宝贵的一课。正当欧美各国纷纷冻结核能计划时,唯有我国高官明知山有虎,偏向虎山行。


山埃冶金厂、稀土提炼厂、核子发电厂,前两者让我们沦为发达国家的排毒工厂,是对纳吉“高收入国”转型计划最大的嘲讽;后者则是一个乞丐穿起龙袍扮太子的不伦不类兼不知所谓。


不论是政府要求人民相信他们具备世界第一流的监管能力,或是人民要求一个连确保天花板不漏水都无法办到的政府担保山埃、稀土、核电的安全,都是强人所难。

15 comments:

Anonymous said...

政府是污桶掌權就把國家當是垃圾桶來管理,真是受不了他們這些害人精!

西澳洲大片沙漠地,幹嘛要山長水遠的來此提炼稀土?虧那衛生部長還 說對方保證顧及安全处理等?!真他*的,怎的這種料也敢當部長,還是終日見報,死愛出風頭的 ” 阿 茂 “!
環境部長也不曉死去那或是又一個內閣集體拿了 回佣或配了股?

連基本的國會大廈,醫院漏水都搞不定,還學人家搞核能计划,真是不知量力!

受夠了,只有把掌權的換掉,才可把這些害人的計划擋下來。

Anonymous said...

Cyanide + Lynas + Neuclear Power = Money Money come

Arm-no + Made Chinese Angree + M-I-See = I want I want

Malaysia boleh - no earthquakes - no Suinami = build neuclear plant ?

A Parent

吴启聪 said...

请大家务实一点!不建这些要怎样提高人民的收入成为“高收入国”?您以为每个人都有钱拔牙妹!

唾棄國陣的大馬公民 said...

請問新加坡有 “建这些” 嗎? 怎的人家又可成為 “高收入国”?

別忘了人家還沒有我們地大又天然資源豐厚。

如不是你等貪官污吏和愚蠢的賣華又賣靈魂的黨領袖和黨員,大馬早就是高收入國了。

這麼愛錢別做 拔牙佬啦!去做鴨吧,別傷害無故的人民。

大佬:“反秤复民” said...

这三间厂,地点都是在彭亨,该州果然是国阵的定期存款。

风语者 said...

除了核能发电厂,马来西亚长年阳光普照,可以考虑的再生电源有好多种。(连一个屋顶都盖不好)为何偏偏好高骛远,不会走想学飞?
心照啦,政府要再搞一个mega project来个袋袋平安。
不要到时又要我们帮他买单!
啊,对了,我们的mega project - Bakun怎样了?

Anonymous said...

helo,dai lor Lim - u sempalit kacang -
Ti lian ker seems like supporting
for it.
wat say u?

Pity Mahmud school produce this type of fan kuat cai

ah beng

吴启聪 said...

到时候核电一起,电费一定比现在降很多的啦!安啦!

賣華黨員最適和守核子发电厂 said...

吳啟聰, 電費降前可能你都已下了地獄 受火刑啦。

吴启聪 said...

凌国文 said...

伟翔,

哈哈,你们马大出产的。

凌大哥,大家都是马来西亚大学出产的!相煎何太急!毕竟大家都是“六日谭”的,好歹我还是您的前辈!请不要长江后浪推前浪,后浪躺在沙滩上!

Anonymous said...

Arsenic gold mining and rare earth processing can be managed in terms of waste management and pollution control. Nuclear power plant is a different story. With the mediocre track record of high tech project management in Malaysia, one nuclear reactor incident can wipe out the existence of Malaysia because it is so small for all the nuclear leak to contaminate every things from air to water to the lands. Then there is no more needs for DAP, Pakatan, BN, and Perkasa. We all become international refugee, some are still rich refugee and most of us will be slaves in other countries. May be that is the destiny from an arrogant decision. The problem with politicians is they are extemely ignorance in this areas and extremely arrogant about it. Imagine no more bumiputra, no more pendatang and all kinds of man made infightings; very peaceful land, with all the rakyat with one form of cancel or another and no hope for the next generations. May be that is the grant plan if we do not vale what we have and cherish the blessings. Let us watch how Japan suffer from the current nuclear reactor incident, it is just unfolding and not done yet. No politician can play the fool with nuclear stuffs.

Anonymous2 said...

"Arsenic gold mining and rare earth processing can be managed in terms of waste management and pollution control."

Agree.

However, knowing very well the work ethic of this government and its people, can you entrust them in managing the radioactive waste? Look at the various fail projects and the leakages from the roof top of the parliament building and the hospitals, MACC staff downloading and watching porno in the office etc is self evident of the level of trustworthiness and assurance of responsibilities of 'our' people.

Can Lynas pass the Aussie' stringent standard in environmental protection act? Has not Lynas already admitted that they are 'researching' ways of using the 3rd stage by-products?

China already suffering from the adverse impact to their their environment with this rare earth processing, shouldn't we be more cautious about it?

We know 'our' government and people, particularly 'our' politicians. Have they ever give us a good track record of credibility and accountability?

The very fact that they can't even handle simple tasks with credential yet insisting on the nuclear power project despite of what is happening in Japan, give us every good reason to question their 'agenda'.

吴启聪 said...

坦白說,民聯在這屆砂州選舉,有一點做得並不漂亮,那就是民聯諸黨為競選選區分配,未戰先亂,讓砂州人民留下不好印象。砂州國陣當然樂得坐山觀虎鬥。民聯最致命的問題所在,除了成員黨之間理念分歧,其次就是資源分配,包括選區和權利。除了行動黨,民聯其他成員黨的選情,均不被看好,國陣要捍衛砂州 政權,可以說毫無懸念,要保住三分二優勢,預料也能低空飛過。

Anonymous said...

We keep complaining about the government; just remember this government is elected by the people.So,the root of problem goes back to the rakyat. What u get is what u ask for. Can Pakatan do a better job? May be, May be not.

Anonymous said...

近期有选举,麻花突然的这样的有活力?楼上的吴别别突然的回复这样多无理头comment?

1. 难到只有起nuclear plant才能变成高收入国?那就请说说下能容下几个就业机会?到头来还不是一个‘我们没有这方面的专才’,然后又在请外国专家?

2. bakun水坝都还没起好就来个nuclear plant, 好像我们这里很缺电这样?

如果还是坚持要起核电厂,我希望能建在either:
1. putrajaya (万事都放心,安啦,有首相看着,不要然突然间首相属会全部搬去sarawak就好鸟)
2. johor (如果有什么事情,我相信singapore会第一时间跑过来帮忙的,又是国震麻花的堡垒区,应该多多照顾他们的)


-枫-