Thursday, June 2, 2011

“以华制华”的2点疑问

马华最近上至领袖,下至文棍,个个都把“以华制华”挂在嘴边,导致“以华制华”四个字人气狂飙,锋芒盖过不汤不水连马华自己都不好意思多讲的“高调问政”四字。

不过,“以华制华”这个概念有两个叫我想不通的地方:

1)如果说华人投票支持马华以外的政党,叫做“以华制华”;那么早在民主行动党壮大以前,这数十年来民政党不是也在分薄马华的华人支持率吗?何故马华几十年来都忘记谴责民政党“以华制华”?再说,何故马华数十年来都不敢批判拉拢民政加入国阵“以华制华”的罪魁祸首巫统

2)马华之所以认为“以华制华”不好,肯定是因为他们认为还有另外一个更可怕的敌人,所以华人必需团结对抗。既然如此,马华何不对华社晓以大义,直接告诉大家,那个更可怕的敌人到底是谁?

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

A proverb said: United is strength !
Chinese community since its independence has always stand behind MCA giving strong supports, especially those in commercial and english learning groups. It was also known as 'Party Taukeh' in the early stage.
However since after modernisation and chinese ethic joined in during the president Lee's periods, MCA has almost covered up all groups of life of chinese community inclusive the labourers. And its most powerful and supports should be at that time. Nevertheess, the leaders did not do a good jobs as expected by the chinese, hence has setback and followed with numerous internal power crazy, the chinese people has realized that no longer to trust them in helping the chinese society on a better future in respect of economic, equality, fair and justice and the transparency of good governance.
So called chinese vs chinese, it is merely a term to accuse the oppornent and hidden their own weaknesses, in a democratic system of principals every citizen has the right to choose the 'best' candidate out of a contesting party. Furthermore civilization and in search of excellence and competency of the people in this modernise world render a direct impact of 'change' in mind revolutions. In short it is not the chinese vs chinese to drain them out but the theory of capable and talented leaders with advance knowledge and technology be elected.
Man brains are suppose to be ahead of all and leading the world !

A Parent

大佬:“反秤复民” said...

以华制华,是污桶的高招,却被卖华赖在火箭和安华身上。

Anonymous said...

i write english because laptop dont gave mandarin input. But i will be direct in my comment - MCA is a political party, it will always be political, so even some slogan sounds the most stupid in the world, it will still say it.

Democracy allows the existence of parties, so if you can form MCA, other people sure can also form Gerakan, DAP, SUPP, PPP, PUKI or whatever. MCA can represent Chinese, other people can also represent Chinese. Since when a Chinese must always allowed themselves to be represented by MCA? Ikut suka akulah parti mana aku nak pilih, itu hak aku.

"Yi Hua Zhi Hua"? then how about Kuomintang fight Mingjintang? also chinese fighting Chinese, no problem, the country progress as usual. It is democracy, it is people's right. The Federal Constitution did not say "when Chinese is born in Malaysia, they must register as MCA member because MCA is the only party that can represent Chinese". Ada kah Perlembagaan Persekutuan said like that?

So dear MCA, i know MCA has a great history, got many leaders, got many taukeh, ministers, deputy ministers, state exco here n there, remember, u did not get to those position by birth, people ELECTED you. So if you cannot win over the voters, jangan cakap banyak, fight like a gentleman and stop talk cock so that people can respect you as a good fighter with dignity.

sekian, terima kasih.

Chua Sui Sui.

Anonymous said...

這個馬華塚會長真是最令人討厭,最和人民 ‘脫結’ 的一個,他的口既多又臭!人民的知識水平和民主意識都提升了,他還活在70‘,80’年代前那框框里,真搞不懂馬華年青的一輩如何受得了這麼一個‘老爺’!還是馬青也思維‘打結’了?

就如大家說的,華人幹嘛一定要支持馬華? 這不是民主國家嗎?如不是,他就大聲宣告呀!如是,即便真有 “以华制华” 這一回事,選民願意,那又怎樣? 馬華該問自己,為何華裔選民唾棄它?不說別的,就拿最 ‘新鮮滾熱辣’ 的 IPP 的合約,這個馬華塚會長一開 ’金口‘ 就讓人民倒盡胃口!只有傻的,沒長腦袋的會票投馬華,當然那些奸詐,貪腐有利益關係的商人和作夢都想當官發不義之財之輩 為例外。

Anonymous said...

This is a low ball scare tactic. Malaysian Chinese has no where to turn to other than DAP or PAS, or migrate oversea. It is a matter of time political party which cannot deliver will cease to exist. Time is running short.

Anonymous said...

Chines versus Chinese, Malays versus Malays, Indians versus Indian, all these will not matter anymore, Malaysian will vote any party which do the right things for the country and its people and make the country stronger in international standing. Life is getting very tough, very dangerous, very unsafe.

Anonymous said...

Today's MSM reported that CSL threatened that if MshitA loses in the next GE, not only the MshitA ministers, but the low ranking hospital's 巡察員 ( Btw, can someone enlighten me what is this? ) da..da.. all in over 10,000 will lose their 'jobs'. Aiyo, I can't imagine the mentality & intelligence of the MshitA's members and supporters, willingly to be 'bastardize' ( Thanks to PM's brother to teach me this word ) by such leader.

With this kind of cheap party, not to say PAS with human candidate, even if the opposition field a pig, I will vote for the latter, at least can slaughter and roast it for some good purpose.

Anonymous said...

馬華中委會會議一致通過,若來屆大選的支持率比308政治大海嘯低將不入閣,這也影響目前1萬1000名馬華代表的官職。出席中委會的領袖包括馬華副總會長拿督斯裡黃燕燕、拿督林祥才、顏炳壽、總秘書拿督斯裡江作漢、副總財政拿督邱克海、全國組織秘書長拿督鄭修強、全國副組織秘書長王賽芝、中委拿督李志亮和受邀列席中委會的農業和農基工業副部長蔡智勇。

***** 在如此关键时刻,没有魏博士的名字,又是没出席吗?是恰好放假还是恰好身体不舒服还是恰好跟首相或副首相开会?以上的借口都是魏博士以前用过的,所以希望这次有新的理由出现,不好又把旧桥重新循环。